Mom’s Maple Butter Tarts
- Prep time 40 mins
- Cook time 20 mins
- Ready in 1 hour
- Yield 24 small tarts
This is a beloved family recipe – my take on my mom’s butter tart recipe. These are small, two-bite wonders, with a shatteringly crisp pastry and a maple-scented filling. The smaller size gives them a better pastry-to filling ratio and a less cloyingly sweet taste. You can use this recipe to make the regular size (see variation). Raisins are a must, in my opinion, but my sister strongly disagrees, so my mom always split the batch in half.
Ingredients
- Sour Cream Pastry
- Tart Filling
Items added to shopping list, click "My Shopping List" along the top to view your list
Directions
- Pastry: Whisk together the flour and salt. Add cold butter, cubed, and cut in until the butter is very small, the size of cornmeal, more or less. In a separate small bowl whisk together the sour cream and cold water until evenly blended.
- Drizzle cold water mixture in to flour-butter mixture, mixing quickly with a fork while drizzling. Use your hands to bring the pastry together. It will seem dry, but keep working it. Divide into two, flatten each half into a large disk, wrap in saran wrap, and refrigerate for two hours.
- Roll out pastry very very thin and cut with 4-inch round scalloped biscuit cutter. Place rounds of pastry into shallow muffin tins (e.g. tart tins), fitting tightly to the bottoms. TIP: Do not worry if the pastry is a bit taller than the edges of the tart cups. Refrigerate pastry or tart shells while making the filling.
- Preheat oven to 385 F.
- Filling: In a large measuring cup, whisk together the melted butter, brown sugar, maple syrup, egg, heavy cream, vanilla, and salt until smooth.
- Pull pastry-lined tin from refrigerator. TIP: If using raisins and/or nuts, place a few of each into the bottom of each tart shell, instead of trying to mix them into the filling.
- Whisk the sugar filling again until well-blended. Use the pouring spout of the measuring cup to pour the filling into each tart shell until it is no more than 2/3 full. TIP: Do not over-fill! The filling will puff up and bubble over.
- Place in the oven and bake for 20 minutes until pastry is golden and filling is set. Remove to a rack to let cool completely before removing tarts from the pan.
Variations
Full-sized muffin tin: For more traditional-sized butter tarts, cut the pastry into 6 or 7-inch circles and line a regular muffin tin. Use more filling per tart and bake for 25 to 30 minutes. The recipe will make 12 to 16 regular sized tarts










































































































































































































































































